Supreme Court slams the CLAT Consortium over 2025 exam errors, urges establishment of a permanent exam authority
The Supreme Court of India has recently expressed strong criticism towards the Consortium of National Law Universities (NLUs) regarding the administration of the Common Law Admission Test for Undergraduates (CLAT-UG) 2025. The Court highlighted significant concerns over errors in the examination and emphasized the necessity for a permanent mechanism to oversee the test's conduct.
Key Issues Identified
- Question Paper Errors: The Supreme Court identified multiple errors in the CLAT-UG 2025 question paper. Some answer keys were found to contradict previous Supreme Court judgments, and at least one question required detailed calculations, which were deemed inappropriate for an objective legal reasoning test.
- Criticism of the Consortium: The bench, comprising Justices Bhushan R. Gavai and Augustine George Masih, expressed "anguish" over the "casual manner" in which the Consortium framed the examination questions. The Court questioned the credibility of the Consortium, noting that if it consisted of vice-chancellors claiming academic excellence, it was necessary to scrutinize who was responsible for the flawed questions.
Supreme Court's Directives
- Revisions to Marking Scheme: The Court ordered corrections to the marking scheme of six questions, directing the Consortium to award marks to candidates who selected certain options and to revise the merit list accordingly.
- Call for Permanent Conducting Mechanism: The Supreme Court urged the Central Government to consider establishing a permanent framework for conducting CLAT, like national-level entrance tests like NEET and JEE, to safeguard student interests and ensure consistency in the examination process.
Background
The CLAT-UG 2025 examination was conducted on December 1, 2024, with results declared on December 7, 2024. Following the examination, multiple petitions were filed across different high courts alleging discrepancies in the question paper. On February 6, 2025, the Supreme Court transferred all such cases to the Delhi High Court to ensure a unified decision. The Delhi High Court, on April 23, 2025, identified errors in four questions and directed the Consortium to revise the marksheets and publish an updated list of selected candidates within four weeks. However, the Supreme Court stayed this order on April 30, 2025, and subsequently issued its own directives on May 7, 2025
Implications
The Supreme Court's intervention underscores the importance of maintaining rigorous standards in national-level entrance examinations. The call for a permanent conducting mechanism aims to prevent future errors and ensure fairness and transparency in the CLAT examination process.Candidates are advised to stay updated with official announcements from the Consortium of NLUs regarding the revised merit list and any changes to the admission process.







